TaxcodeIN Today | Daily GST Updates | 06 October 2026

GST Daily Updates

06 October 2026

—

GST Laws

High Courts

1. Maple Overseas Trade Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors. – (2026) taxcode.in 1604 HC

Tribunal dismissal for non-prosecution can be remanded where hearing notices were inadequate and appeal was otherwise duly constituted

The High Court held that the GST appellate framework under Section 111 permits dismissal of an appeal for want of prosecution and also provides a remedy to set aside such dismissal, but the petitioner should not be left remediless on the facts of this case. The first appeal had been filed with the statutory pre-deposit, yet it was dismissed after hearing notices uploaded on the GST portal were allegedly not properly communicated. The Court found that an order on merits was warranted in the first appeal and therefore set aside the dismissal order. The matter was remanded to the Appellate Authority for fresh decision after due opportunity of hearing, with a direction for the appellant to appear on the specified date.

2. Jagdish Prasad Agrawal v. Union of India and Ors. – (2026) taxcode.in 1581 HC

Blocking of electronic credit ledger under Rule 86A requires recorded reasons and strict compliance with statutory preconditions

The Court reiterated that Rule 86A lays down mandatory preconditions before the Electronic Credit Ledger can be blocked, including reasons to believe and reasons recorded in writing by the competent authority. On the material placed, those requirements had not been complied with. However, since the ledger was no longer blocked and had become operational, the Court confined itself to the surviving issue, accepted the unconditional apology tendered on behalf of the officer, and disposed of the writ petition. The order also cautioned the respondents that any future action taken without due compliance with Rule 86A would expose them to liability to pay appropriate compensation to the aggrieved party.

3. Shubham Kumar v. Commissioner of Customs and Anr. – (2026) taxcode.in 1574 HC

Cancellation of GST registration set aside where only one notice was issued and taxpayer showed cause for non-response

The Court found that the petitioner had explained why he could not respond to the show-cause notice or attend the hearing, and that adequate opportunity required fixation of another date when only one notice had been issued. It also noted that the cancellation order appeared to have been passed without fixing any further hearing. The authority was directed to examine the petitioner’s claim that the relevant return had been filed on 15.04.2023 and, if it had not been filed, to consider whether filing could still be permitted on payment of taxes, penalty and fine. The impugned cancellation and appellate orders were set aside and the matter was remanded for fresh consideration after giving the petitioner an opportunity to file a response and be heard.

Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT)

4. Vardhman Yarns and Threads Ltd. v. Commissioner of Commercial Taxes and Ors. – (2026) taxcode.in 208 GSTAT

Detention at consignee’s gate for missing Part-B update held illegal when goods had completed transit and records matched

The Tribunal held that Section 129 could not be invoked where the vehicle had already completed its journey and was stationary at the consignee’s gate. The only lapse was non-update of Part-B of the e-way bill, which was immediately corrected once pointed out. Since the goods were supported by invoices and generated Part-A, matched the consignment, and caused no revenue loss, the omission was treated as a bona fide technical lapse rather than a substantive contravention. The adjudication was also found vulnerable because the personal hearing became meaningless when the order bore an earlier date, and that objection was ignored in appeal. The detention, tax demand and equal penalty were therefore set aside, and refund with statutory interest was directed.

5. Poobalan Sureshbabu v. Mansoor Pasha and Ors. – (2026) taxcode.in 209 GSTAT

Appeal before GSTAT rejected as defective after repeated failure to cure registry objections and pay minimum fee

The Tribunal rejected the appeal as defective after the appellant failed to cure 33 registry objections and did not appear despite repeated opportunities. The defects included missing certified copies, absent statement of facts and case summary, incomplete translations, faulty indexing and authentication, and non-compliance with the minimum court-fee requirement, with only Rs. 1,000 paid against the prescribed minimum of Rs. 5,000. The Tribunal noted that the defects remained uncured within the stipulated period of 30 days from the defect memo and that the appellant showed complete disregard for the repeated chances granted over about two months. In view of the persistent default, the appeal was dismissed as defective.

6. JSW Steel Coated Products Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Appeals) and Ors. – (2026) taxcode.in 193 GSTAT

Expired e-way bill alone does not justify detention and penalty absent evidence of tax evasion or revenue loss

The Tribunal held that Section 129 must be applied with due regard to the distinction between serious contraventions and minor procedural lapses. In this case, the consignment was accompanied by invoices, lorry receipt, e-way bills and a test certificate, and physical verification showed no discrepancy between the goods and the records. The only defect was expiry of the e-way bill, which arose from an incorrect destination entry, and there was no finding that the movement caused tax evasion or loss of revenue. The Tribunal accepted that the reasonableness of the taxpayer’s explanation was relevant and found the invocation of Section 129 unjustified. The order confirming integrated tax and penalty was set aside and the appeal was allowed.

7. Excel Steel v. Commissioner of State Tax – (2026) taxcode.in 217 GSTAT

Penalty under Section 129 cannot survive vague notices, non-supply of statements and order passed without hearing

The Tribunal held that Section 129 requires a specific contravention of the Act or Rules to be pleaded and established by evidence. Here, the show-cause notice did not specify the statutory provisions allegedly violated, and the proceedings were further vitiated because copies of the driver’s and manager’s statements were not supplied to the appellant. The Tribunal also found that the order in original was passed before the scheduled hearing, leaving the portion meant for the appellant’s submissions blank and showing that no effective hearing was granted. The appellate authority had also failed to deal with the specific pleas and had not made out any clear case of contravention. On these grounds, the penalty under Section 129 was held unsustainable and the appeal was allowed with consequential relief.

8. Suman Patel v. Punit Kumar Aggarwal – (2026) taxcode.in 225 GSTAT

Departmental appeal below monetary limit dismissed where Revenue failed to plead or prove any recognised exception

The Tribunal dismissed the departmental appeal at the admission stage because the disputed amount of Rs. 10,62,900 was below the Rs. 20,00,000 monetary limit prescribed by the applicable circular. It held that the right of appeal is statutory but subject to the statutory and administrative conditions governing its exercise, and that maintainability must be examined before merits. The Revenue had neither pleaded nor established any recognised exception, such as a constitutional challenge, invalidity of a rule or circular, recurring legal issue, adverse comments or a recorded opinion by the Commissioner. The Tribunal clarified that authorisation under Section 112(3) does not dispense with compliance with Section 120 and the monetary-limit instructions. Since no exception was shown, the appeal was not admitted.

9. Sandeep Tiwari v. J. M. R. Equipments – (2026) taxcode.in 223 GSTAT

Revenue appeal dismissed where Commissioner’s approval could not replace proof of exception to monetary-limit policy

The Tribunal held that departmental appeals under Section 112 must also satisfy the binding monetary-limit instructions issued under Section 120, and that admission is not automatic. Since the disputed amount was Rs. 7,36,272, below the Rs. 20,00,000 threshold, the Revenue was required to specifically identify and establish a recognised exception before the appeal could be admitted. The record contained no material showing such an exception, no recurring legal issue, no challenge to any provision or circular, and no recorded Commissioner’s opinion justifying the appeal despite the limit. The Tribunal reiterated that mere authorisation by the Commissioner is insufficient. As the conditions for admission were not met, the appeal was dismissed at threshold without examining merits.

10. Pratibha Rai v. Parle Biscuits Pvt. Ltd. – (2026) taxcode.in 202 GSTAT

Repeated failure to remove defects justified threshold dismissal of State appeal involving minor invoice discrepancies

The Tribunal declined to grant any further opportunity after the appellant repeatedly failed to remove defects despite several chances. It noted the first appellate findings that the respondent was a bona fide GST-registered company and that the minor discrepancies did not justify an inference of intention to evade tax. The disputed tax and penalty were also stated to be below Rs. 2 lakh. In those circumstances, the Tribunal held that continued default showed lack of diligence on the part of the State and that further indulgence would not be in the interest of justice. The appeal was therefore dismissed at that stage, with each party left to bear its own costs.

11. Maltown Electrics Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Tax and Ors. – (2026) taxcode.in 207 GSTAT

Interest survives where ITC was retained beyond 180 days, but penalty under Section 74 failed for bona fide dispute

The Tribunal held that the second proviso to Section 16(2) was breached when part of the invoice value remained unpaid beyond 180 days and no agreement showing discount within that period was produced, so proportionate credit should have been added to the output tax liability with interest. However, it also found that the later waiver through a financial or commercial credit note meant no amount towards the value of supply ultimately remained payable, and that the recipient was entitled to retain the original ITC under the third proviso to Section 16(2) read with Rule 37(4). The Tribunal treated the issue as bona fide and found no fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression, with Section 75(2) enabling treatment of the notice under Section 73. The demand of ITC and penalty under Section 74 was set aside, but interest under Section 50 for the intervening period was sustained.

12. Bos Natural Flavours Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Kerala State GST – (2026) taxcode.in 218 GSTAT

GST appeal remanded where dismissal for non-payment of court fee overlooked earlier legal position and taxpayer’s offer to comply

The Tribunal limited itself to the legality of dismissal on the court-fee issue and did not go into the tax merits. It noted that the applicability of court fee on GST first appeals before Kerala State authorities had already been settled by the Kerala High Court before the appeal in question was filed. While Section 107(6) deals with pre-deposit requirements, the State appellate authority, as a public servant, remained bound by the Kerala Court Fees and Suits Valuation Act. At the same time, the appellant undertook before the Tribunal to pay the requisite fee. The impugned order was therefore set aside and the matter was remanded to the first appellate authority for decision on merits within three months after following natural justice.

Other Laws

High Courts

13. Ajmunbi Shaik v. Chief Commissioner of Customs and Ors. – (2026) taxcode.in 1579 HC

Redemption of confiscated gold jewellery cannot be refused mechanically merely because goods are treated as prohibited

The Court held that even where goods are treated as prohibited, discretion under Section 125 cannot be exercised mechanically and must be applied judiciously on the facts of each case. The petitioner had been intercepted at the airport with gold jewellery concealed on his person, and confiscation had been confirmed in appeal; however, the Court noted that there was nothing to suggest a serious or previous violation, and that penalty had already been imposed and paid. It also referred to the statutory limit under the second proviso to Section 125 for determining redemption fine. The refusal to permit redemption was therefore set aside to that extent, and the adjudicating authority was directed to determine redemption fine in accordance with law, after which the gold jewellery was to be released within the prescribed time.

Scroll to Top