The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Kolkata Bench, has allowed the appeal of Crochet Trade and Investment Pvt. Ltd. for assessment year 2009-10 after finding that the Revenue could not establish issuance of a notice under Section 143(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, following the assessee’s return in response to a reopening notice under Section 148.
Accountant Member Laxmi Prasad Sahu ruled that issuance of a Section 143(2) notice is mandatory for the Assessing Officer to assume jurisdiction to complete an assessment where a valid return has been filed in response to a Section 148 notice. The Tribunal also found that Section 292BB could not assist the Revenue because there was no record to show that such notice had in fact been issued.
Reassessment and addition
The assessee had filed its original return on 25 September 2009, declaring income of Rs. 81,470. The return was processed under Section 143(1) on 25 March 2011.
Subsequently, the Assessing Officer reopened the case after obtaining approval from the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Income Tax-2, Kolkata. A notice under Section 148 dated 31 March 2016 was issued, allowing 30 days from service for compliance.
In response, the company filed a return on 22 April 2016 declaring the same income and sought the reasons recorded for reopening. The reasons were supplied on 20 May 2016. The assessment was thereafter completed under Sections 148, 147 and 144, with an addition of Rs. 15,45,968. The assessed income was determined at Rs. 16,27,456.
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) dismissed the company’s appeal, following which it approached the Tribunal.
Challenge based on Section 143(2) notice
Before the Tribunal, the assessee argued that it had filed its return within the time allowed under the Section 148 notice, but the Assessing Officer did not issue a notice under Section 143(2) before completing the reassessment. It contended that the assessment was therefore void from the outset because the notice was necessary for the Assessing Officer to assume jurisdiction after a valid return had been filed.
The Departmental Representative relied on the orders of the lower authorities and submitted that the reassessment had been completed after due approval from the competent authority. It was also submitted that reasons for reopening had been furnished to the assessee within the time sought.
In rejoinder, the assessee submitted that the Revenue had not proved issuance of the Section 143(2) notice. It pointed out that the assessment order itself did not record issuance of such notice and contended that Section 292BB would consequently have no application.
Tribunal finds no proof of statutory notice
The Tribunal noted that the assessee had filed its return on 22 April 2016 within the period allowed under the notice issued under Section 148. It treated the central issue as whether the Assessing Officer had issued a Section 143(2) notice before completing the assessment or within the prescribed period.
According to the order, the Departmental Representative could not controvert the assessee’s contention and did not produce documentary material showing that notice under Section 143(2) had been issued before completion of assessment.
The Tribunal stated that issuance of notice under Section 143(2) is a mandatory requirement for the Assessing Officer to assume jurisdiction to complete the assessment when a valid return is filed by the assessee. It further held that Section 292BB would not help the Revenue in the circumstances, since the record did not suggest that any Section 143(2) notice had been issued.
For this conclusion, the Bench followed the Raipur Tribunal’s decision in Balbir Singh v. ACIT, which had treated the absence of a Section 143(2) notice after a return filed in response to Section 148 as a jurisdictional defect and had quashed the assessment in that case.
Appeal allowed; other grounds not addressed
Respectfully following that decision, the Kolkata Bench allowed the assessee’s appeal. The Tribunal’s ruling was confined to the jurisdictional defect arising from the absence of proof of issuance of the mandatory Section 143(2) notice.
The appeal had also raised objections concerning the reopening process and the disallowance of derivative-transaction loss of Rs. 15,45,968. However, the order allowed the appeal on the Section 143(2) issue and did not separately adjudicate those other grounds.
The decision underscores that, where an assessee files a valid return in compliance with a Section 148 notice, the Revenue must be able to show issuance of a Section 143(2) notice before completing the reassessment. Mere participation in proceedings cannot cure the position under Section 292BB where no record exists of the notice having been issued.
Reported Case Details
Case Name: Crochet Trade and Investment Pvt. Ltd. v. ITO
Case Citation: (2026) taxcode.in 60 ITAT








