The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram Bench, has held that when a job worker returns processed goods to the principal, the value of the principal’s original goods is not to be included in the consignment value declared in the e-way bill. The Tribunal allowed Metalloids India’s appeal, set aside the appellate order sustaining a penalty under Section 129 of the CGST/SGST Acts, and granted consequential relief.
In its order dated September 17, 2026, the Bench comprising Vice-President Subramanya V. Rayaprol and Technical Member Ramamoorthi Sriram found that the supply on return of goods after job work was the job-work service. Therefore, the relevant transaction value for the e-way bill was limited to the job-work charges and applicable tax, rather than the value of materials originally sent by the principal.
Interception and penalty proceedings
The matter arose from the interception on May 4, 2023 of a vehicle carrying aluminium colour-coated coils and GI sheets from Roofstyle Industries, the job worker, to Metalloids India at Pathanamthitta. The department alleged that the goods were not accompanied by valid documents and that no e-way bill accompanied the consignment.
A penalty of Rs. 1,25,442 each under the CGST and SGST Acts, aggregating to Rs. 2,50,884, was imposed under Section 129(3). Metalloids India paid the amount to obtain release of the goods and vehicle, but its appeal was dismissed by the Joint Commissioner (Appeals), SGST, Kottayam.
Before the Tribunal, the appellant maintained that the goods were being returned after completion of job work and that the movement was accompanied by the job-work invoice, an e-way bill generated on the invoice value, the original delivery challan and other documents. It contended that the value of the principal’s goods could not be treated as part of the taxable supply by the job worker.
Documents were available at interception, Tribunal finds
The Tribunal first examined the allegations in the show-cause notice. It noted that the annexure to the driver’s statement in Form GST MOV-04 recorded that Invoice No. 047 dated May 4, 2023 had been tendered at the time of interception.
According to the Tribunal, the invoice issued by Roofstyle Industries to Metalloids India contained the mandatory particulars, including the description, quantity and HSN of the goods, the job-work charges and GST paid on those charges. It consequently found that the consignment was accompanied by a valid tax-paid invoice. Once such an invoice accompanied the goods, the Tribunal said, there was no separate requirement for a delivery challan.
It further noted that Delivery Challan No. 3 dated May 4, 2023, issued by Metalloids India, was also listed among the documents tendered at interception. Referring to paragraph 8.4(i) of CBIC Circular No. 38/12/2018, as reproduced in the order, the Tribunal found that the appellant had complied with the documentation requirement relating to goods returned by a job worker.
The Tribunal also recorded that E-Way Bill No. 521496456415 for the movement from Roofstyle Industries to Metalloids India was shown in the annexure to Form GST MOV-01. It held that the allegation in the show-cause notice that no e-way bill had accompanied the goods was contradicted by the department’s own documents.
Value of job-work service governs e-way bill value
The Revenue argued before the Tribunal that the return e-way bill showed zero quantity and only the job-work invoice value of Rs. 1,841, despite goods valued at Rs. 6,96,900 being transported. It submitted that the e-way bill should capture both the original material value and the job-work charges.
The Tribunal rejected this contention. It noted that the Revenue had not identified a statutory provision supporting its position. Referring to Explanation 2 to Rule 138 of the KGST/CGST Rules and Section 15(1) of the CGST Act, the Bench concluded that consignment value is the value declared in the relevant invoice, bill of supply or delivery challan and is determined in accordance with Section 15.
On a conjoint reading of those provisions, the Tribunal held that where a job worker returns goods to the principal after completing job work, the supply is only of job-work services. The transaction value is accordingly restricted to the job-work charges plus applicable duties, and the value of the original goods subjected to job work is not includable in the consignment value reported in the e-way bill.
In this case, the job-work invoice value was Rs. 1,841, inclusive of job-work charges and applicable CGST and SGST. As there was no allegation that the parties were related or that the invoice amount was not the sole consideration, the Tribunal accepted Rs. 1,841 as the transaction value and consignment value. This amount was below the Rs. 50,000 threshold stated in Rule 138(1) for issuance of an e-way bill.
The Bench therefore found that e-way bill regulations did not mandatorily apply to this return movement. It held that proceedings founded on an alleged defective e-way bill or absence of an e-way bill were void ab initio in the facts of the case.
Orders went beyond the show-cause notice
The Tribunal also found procedural defects in the departmental orders. The show-cause notice alleged that no e-way bill accompanied the goods, but the order under Section 129(3) treated the e-way bill as invalid. The Tribunal held that the order could not introduce this new ground when it was not part of the show-cause notice.
It further found that the detention order did not provide reasons for concluding that the e-way bill was invalid. This rendered the order non-speaking and violated principles of natural justice, the Tribunal said.
The appellate authority had acknowledged that an e-way bill generated at 3.47 pm on May 4, 2023 covered transport from Roofstyle Industries to Metalloids India. However, it proceeded to rely on the absence of an e-way bill for transport from A.S. Metals, Kochi to Metalloids India. The Tribunal held that this was an irrelevant ground outside the scope of the show-cause notice and unrelated to the journey during which the goods were intercepted.
Answering the stated question of law in the negative, the Tribunal ruled that the value of goods belonging to the principal, when returned by the job worker after completion of job work, is not includable in the e-way bill’s consignment value. It set aside the Order-in-Appeal and allowed Metalloids India’s appeal with consequential relief.
Reported Case Details
Case Name: Metalloids India v. Commissioner of State Tax
Case Citation: (2026) taxcode.in 215 GSTAT








